{
  "title": "Fine arts critique and version data for AI",
  "source_page": "https://fiund.com/industries/fine-arts-critique-version-data",
  "authorship": "Original fictional Fiund editorial exercise. No actual operating records or third-party source assets are included.",
  "example": {
    "title": "A critique's version reference matters as much as its wording",
    "context": "An instructor creates two original abstract sketches. The task links comments to versions and distinguishes a visible change from a subjective artistic judgment.",
    "records": [
      [
        "FA1",
        "Owned sketch version A",
        "Central triangle is solid blue. Critique CA says the central region looks visually heavy."
      ],
      [
        "FA2",
        "Owned sketch version B",
        "Central triangle now outlined; version-specific critique CB acknowledges that change but still calls the composition heavy."
      ],
      [
        "FA3",
        "Unlinked annotation",
        "Comment says remove the red circle; neither A nor B contains a red circle, and no artwork ID is supplied."
      ]
    ],
    "question": "Which factual change is documented between A and B, and does the continuing subjective critique or unrelated annotation override it?",
    "answer": "FA1 and FA2 document a change from a solid-blue central triangle to an outlined triangle. CB explicitly recognizes that change while retaining a subjective impression of heaviness; the opinion does not show that the edit failed to occur. FA3 has no matching artwork feature or version identity. Keep it unassigned rather than inventing a red circle or treating it as a critique of B.",
    "failureModes": [
      "Using a subjective repeated opinion to deny a visible documented edit.",
      "Assigning an annotation to an artwork that lacks the named feature and identifier."
    ],
    "fields": [
      [
        "Artwork version",
        "Links factual observations to the correct image."
      ],
      [
        "Comment source and reference",
        "Preserves which version a critique names."
      ],
      [
        "Factual versus subjective statement",
        "Prevents taste judgments from becoming objective change labels."
      ]
    ],
    "holdout": "Create version C restoring the solid triangle while changing a different feature. Ask the model to describe the actual version-to-version edits rather than a presumed linear improvement.",
    "boundary": "Use instructor-owned original work and commentary with explicit rights. Exclude student portfolios, identities, personal assessments and third-party art."
  }
}